| De Niro, Robert |
Paul Vitti |
| Crystal, Billy |
Dr. Ben Sobel |
| Kudrow, Lisa |
Laura MacNamara Sobel |
| Palminteri, Chazz |
Primo Sidone |
| Novakovic, Kresimir |
'50s Gangster |
| Tangredi, Bart |
Young Vitti Sr. |
| Straka, Michael |
Young Dominic Manetta |
| Rigano, Joseph |
Dominic Manetta (as Joe Rigano) |
| Viterelli, Joe |
Jelly |
| Castellano, Richard C. |
Jimmy Boots (as Richard Castellano) |
| Shannon, Molly |
Caroline |
| Casella, Max |
Nicky Shivers |
| Pietrangolare, Frank |
Tuna |
| Sabihy, Kyle |
Michael Sobel |
| Macy, Bill |
Dr. Isaac Sobel |
| Schull, Rebecca |
Dorothy Sobel |
| Cooper, Pat |
Salvatore Masiello |
| Rossi, Leo |
Carlo Mangano |
| Mandvi, Aasif |
Dr. Shulman |
| Pepe, Neil |
Carl |
| Darrow, Tony |
Moony |
| Haley, Michael |
Producer (as R.M. Haley) |
| Marioles, Ian |
Soundman |
| Recco, Donnamarie |
Sheila |
| Cecere, Vince |
Tino |
| Weeks, Jimmie Ray |
FBI Agent Steadman |
| Cea, Bob |
FBI Agent Ricci (as Robert Cea) |
| Hill, William |
FBI Agent Provano |
| Wheeler, Ira |
Scott MacNamara |
| Ennis, Luce |
Belinda MacNamara |
| Bracco, Elizabeth |
Marie Vitti |
| Gallagher, Gina |
Theresa Vitti |
| Mari, Francesca |
Anna Vitti |
| Vella, Jr., Vinny |
Anthony Vitti (as Vincent Vella Jr.) |
| Bruno, Mickey |
Miami Soldier |
| Corey, Dave |
Miami Hall Guard |
| Workman, Fred |
Justice of the Peace |
| Barringer, Daniel W. |
Dream Sequence Gunman |
| Polce, John |
Dream Sequence Gunman (as John J. Polce) |
| Eliot, Drew |
Priest at Funeral |
| DeSena, Grace |
Tommy Angels' Widow |
| Catalfumo, New York Joe |
Exuberant Mourner |
| Guarino, Jr., Michael |
Stevie Beef |
| Harkins, Michael |
Paretti's Family |
| Raflo, Paula |
Paretti's Family |
| Harris, Ondine |
Paretti's Family |
| Vega, Matthew |
Paretti's Family |
| Caserta, Clem |
Handsome Jack |
| Rossi, Tony Ray |
Potatoes |
| Kahan, Judith |
Elaine Felton |
| Neustadt, Ted |
Rabbi |
| Cajano, Pasquale |
Joe Baldassare |
| Ruffini, Gene |
Frankie Zello |
| Sauchelli, Jr., Alfred |
Mo-Mo |
| DiBenedetto, Tony |
Johnny 'Bigs' |
| Aquilino, Frank |
Eddie 'Cokes' |
| Bennett, Tony |
Himself |
| Anastasia, Albert |
Himself (archive footage) |
| Bonanno, Joseph |
Himself (archive footage) |
| Costello, Frank |
Himself (archive footage) |
| Gallo, Albert |
Himself (archive footage) |
| Gallo, Joe |
Himself (archive footage) |
| Gallo, Larry |
Himself (archive footage) |
| Gambino, Carlo |
Himself (archive footage) |
| Genovese, Vito |
Himself (archive footage) |
| Bruce, Tracie |
Bikini Girl (uncredited) |
| Caruso, Phillip V. |
Wedding Photographer (uncredited) |
| Caso, Anthony |
Johnny Angel (uncredited) |
| Russo, Anthony |
Mafia Bodyguard (uncredited) |
